Planning and Forecasting 4 – The Truth Plays Out

As Campbell's Soup learned, no matter how capable and experienced its planners are, their plan is only as good as the information that feeds it. The big "a-ha!" moment at Campbell's Soup came when the S&OP process illustrated exactly how broken many of the company's processes were throughout the organization—from finance to commercialization to label design, custom pack planning, and transportation. S&OP provides a heightened level of transparency to the extent that, over time, as Mastroianni puts it, "the truth plays out." By bringing all of Campbell's business plans into a single, integrated set of plans—the end game of an S&OP initiative—the company was ultimately able to fix a dozen or more major processes.

Sales and operations planning (S&OP) aligns all of a company's business plans (customers, sales and marketing, research and development, production, sourcing, and financial) into a single, integrated set of plans. The end goal is a plan that more accurately forecasts supply and demand.

For instance, Campbell's has improved by as much as 50 percent the weekly accuracy of the item-level signals sent to its manufacturing plants, which resulted in an immediate benefit: The company can now better plan how many trucks it needs to replenish its distribution centers with product. That increased level of accuracy has also paid off by reducing how often Campbell's has to use expedited shipping to make up for not having the right products at its customers at the right time.

Taking it a step further, Campbell's has leveraged its precision of accuracy to provide improved visibility to its warehouses and manufacturing plants. The company has used its long-range planning capabilities to prebuy transportation with some of its carriers. It's also used those forecasts for labor management, specifically in determining when to add extra crews to its warehouses and when to cut back.

There's one last benefit to the best practices Campbell's uses for its supply chain planning: "It makes me sleep real good at night," Mastroianni says. "It's no fun getting your head handed to you."

END-TO-END INTEGRATION

The key to Campbell's S&OP program was being able to integrate all of those different departments and processes into one central plan, and that strategy can be applied in any company in any industry. At computer giant IBM Corp., for instance, integration is not only a key best practice for the company, it's included in the very name of its supply chain organization, the Integrated Supply Chain (ISC).

In 2003, IBM completed an end-to-end integration project that connects all of its business processes and supporting systems into the ISC, an organization employing 19,000 people at more than 50 locations worldwide. The ISC comprises manufacturing, procurement, logistics, distribution, customer ordering, and planning and scheduling— the whole nine yards of supply chain processes.

"There are many factors in supply chain planning," observes Rich Hume, vice president of operations and strategy with the ISC. "Every proposed idea or change at IBM must meet certain criteria. Initiatives must improve customer satisfaction, increase the flexibility of the supply chain, improve economics, and improve functional excellence. Proposals must be executable and include measurable economic results."

Most of IBM's supply chain planning is done internally, involving such departments as logistics, fulfillment, manufacturing, and manufacturing engineering, as well as functional experts in the company's business consulting and business transformation groups.

"In other companies, these professionals are typically aligned with corporate functions like procurement or logistics," Hume notes. "Having them in one organization allows us to take advantage of their expertise within each function, while also benefiting from their integration across the supply chain."